Is AI the future of marketing creativity, or the end of it?

The rise of generative AI tools has sparked both excitement and anxiety across the industry. Headlines proclaim the death of the artist, while tech evangelists tout AI as the ultimate creative solution. The truth, as always, lies somewhere in the middle.

At Halcyon Digital, we believe in embracing new technologies, but not at the expense of human artistry and ethical practices. We see AI as a tool, one that can potentially enhance the creative process in specific ways, but isn’t ready to replace the irreplaceable: the human understanding of human desires, emotions, and experiences. As with every new tool, there is widespread panic, and historically, those who ignore the existence of new technologies are doomed to fall behind.

The AI Dilemma: Promise and Peril

The allure of AI is undeniable. Imagine generating marketing visuals or copy with a few simple text prompts. It sounds like a dream come true for businesses seeking speed and efficiency. But the reality is more complex. While AI can undoubtedly accelerate certain tasks, it also presents significant challenges:

• Ethical Concerns: Many AI image generators are trained on vast datasets scraped from the internet, often without the consent or compensation of the original artists. This raises serious questions about copyright infringement and fair use. Companies like Meta have faced accusations of illegally pirating content to train their models, highlighting the ethical minefield surrounding AI-generated content.
• Lack of Originality: AI, by its nature, remixes existing data. It can create variations on existing themes, but it struggles to produce truly original concepts. The output can often feel generic, lacking certain unique qualities of human creativity.
• Quality Control: AI-generated content can be unpredictable and inconsistent. Results are often hit or miss, requiring human intervention and quality control. Verifying the source and authenticity of AI-generated content, especially on stock footage websites, like Storyblocks, is a growing concern.

Finding the Right Balance: A Principled Approach

So, where does this leave us? At Halcyon Digital, we advocate for a principled and practical approach. We recognize the potential of AI to assist in certain aspects of the marketing process. For example, AI tools can be helpful for:

• Brainstorming and Idea Generation: AI can provide a starting point for creative exploration, offering a diverse range of options to consider.
• Generating Initial Drafts: AI can quickly create rough drafts of copy or storyboards, which can then be refined by human writers and artists.
• Data analysis: Quickly finding trends and irregularities in mountains of data can help us respond quickly to errors or quickly make decisions and change direction or focus in agile marketing campaigns.

We’ve personally experimented with AI text and image generation tools, and while the technology is impressive, it's still far from perfect. Image resolution can be limited, and achieving specific results often requires tedious trial and error with text prompts. It is, however, a great tool to kick off a project or bring a concept to life in a matter of seconds.

However, we firmly believe that AI should never replace human judgment, creativity, and ethical considerations in core marketing activities.

Case Studies: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly

Coca-Cola’s infamous 2024 Christmas commercial provides a glimpse into the potential (and limitations) of AI in high-end marketing. While, as disclosed by Coca-Cola themselves, the ad was AI-generated, we can make an educated guess that it still required significant human intervention to bring to completion: 3D models for objects that need more precise control (like the truck door 55 seconds in here), logo superimposition, and extensive post-processing (color grading, lens flares, etc.). 

Looking into the future a bit, this represents what we would call a more "balanced" approach, something that could very quickly become our new norm – primarily using AI generated video for efficiency, but still relying on human artistry for quality control and brand consistency. 

As it relates to our world right now, Coca-Cola knew that they were striking when the iron was hot. AI is only becoming more and more controversial; what an interesting way to get people talking about your brand, don’t you think?

Conversely, the video game Catly provides a cautionary tale. Simply put, the developers used AI-generated images in their promotional trailer and on their website (many or all of which have been taken down now). While the game itself was not AI-generated, the use of AI in the marketing materials sparked a negative backlash from the community. Gamers, concerned about the ethics and potential for low-quality output, accused the developers of using AI to mislead, discounting the very real hard work of their human artists and developers. This highlights the crucial importance of transparency and the potential for even perceived AI misuse to damage a brand's reputation. Coca-Cola did it right by plainly disclosing their use of AI in their ad.

The Human Element: Still Irreplaceable

Ultimately, marketing is about connecting with people. It's about understanding their needs, desires, and aspirations. It's about telling stories that resonate emotionally. While AI can analyze data and identify patterns, it cannot (yet) replicate the nuanced understanding of human psychology that drives truly effective marketing.

At Halcyon Digital, we're committed to staying at the forefront of technological advancements, including exploring the responsible use of AI. But we will always prioritize human creativity, originality, and ethical practices. We believe that's the right balance, and it's the best way to deliver exceptional results for our clients. Nothing is black and white, this is a time for exploration and experimentation and to find how we can make AI work best for us.

Thank you to the Corridor Crew for their astute AI related observations we referenced in this article.

Ready to discuss how a human-centered, ethically conscious approach to marketing can elevate your brand? Let’s chat!

‍